All the work on anomalies was the perturbation expansion of field theories. The... the theory about invariance of three manifolds. Of course that was a big... big breakthrough and I remember very clearly being at the... at the meeting in Swansea when... when we went out to a restaurant and – Annie's Restaurant it was called – and... and we had dinner. And during the course of the dinner, Graeme Segel and Ed Witten and I… actually the whole thing, you know, emerged and we spent several hours while everybody else had gone away. And Ed Witten was writing on all the napkins and by the end of the evening the whole theory was sort of buttoned up. And the next morning he gave a new talk, cancelled his other talk, and the whole thing was finished. It was, sort of, dramatic.
So it was... it was quite a surprise, but we'd been trying to understand the role of some of those invariants for a while, dimly seeing bits and pieces of how it emerged, so it wasn't... it wasn’t, sort of, a totally new… we knew there was all this quantum field theory, we knew there were these things people were trying to do. It was a quite a, sort of, spectacular when it sort of locked into play like that, so you know, very satisfying. But these things are never as clean cut as they seem, you know, you're gradually learning bits and pieces and trying to pick up the language, and… but obviously that stuff about knot invariants was a very clean example of it all.
But I mean I'd been previously… let's see, I'm trying to remember the order now. There was... there was that work on the Jones polynomial, but before that there'd been the work on the Donaldson theory and I'd already… when I'd talked to the conference about Hermann Weyl, sort of, symposium they held in America… that was before the... the work on three manifolds. And at that stage I was trying to interest the physicists in the three manifold… in the Jones invariants, and trying to speculate they had something to do with gauge theories. And at that time the… and the Donaldson work also, and what Witten… as a result of my, sort of, constantly pestering him when I was at the institute for one term, towards the end of the term he suddenly discovered how to express the Donaldson theory in terms of quantum field theory and how these twisted Yang–Mills theories gave the right answer. And he was very, very excited by that and he thought it was, you know, it was really… it was a big breakthrough.
So there was that one on the one hand, and then the search for the Jones invariants on the other hand, so I was... I was sort of, you know, I was pushing for it behind the scenes. I wasn't actually, sort of, doing the work, Witten was doing the work, but I was actually prodding him saying, ‘There ought to be something like this around’. And so I was very, you know, gratified when it all worked out. So I could see there were these nice tantalising things in mathematics which ought to have [an] explanation in terms of quantum field theory. And you know, it was just the right moment when it actually all... all fell into place.