NEXT STORY
Exciting ideas that ought to be researched
RELATED STORIES
NEXT STORY
Exciting ideas that ought to be researched
RELATED STORIES
Views | Duration | ||
---|---|---|---|
21. Consciousness | 1 | 572 | 03:09 |
22. The little-understood question of cells' positional identity | 362 | 04:55 | |
23. Sydney Brenner: The local genius | 524 | 02:09 | |
24. 'Reading rots the mind' | 817 | 01:04 | |
25. Is science dangerous? | 575 | 04:50 | |
26. The nonsense of bioethics | 1 | 385 | 02:11 |
27. Exciting ideas that ought to be researched | 337 | 02:27 | |
28. The relationship between evolution and development | 275 | 02:22 | |
29. A theory about metamorphosis | 214 | 02:05 | |
30. 'Soil mechanics wasn't very sexy, but then neither was cell... | 186 | 02:45 |
So I want to argue very strongly that the human embryo is not a human being until it’s outside the woman, and can survive outside the mother with a minimum of external… a minimum of external support. And what’s nice about stem cells now, and it’s a remarkable achievement, it’s now possible to make… almost the equivalent of embryonic stem cells by taking one of your skin cells, putting in a certain number of genes, and they almost behave like embryonic stem cells. So those ethical issues thing. And then there was an enormous fuss about cloning… cloning a human being. That is, taking one of my cells, taking the nucleus with its genes, and putting it into a… an egg from which the nucleus has been removed. And of course that would be an identical twin to me when it develops, and people — there was — people have been hysterical about the ethical issues that this ranges. I have to tell you that I have offered on television, radio and the press, a bottle of champagne to anybody who can show me — or tell me — one new ethical issue that this raises. There’s a further complication. If you come and ask for your bottle of champagne and I show you that you’re wrong and it’s not new, you have to give me two. Nobody has ever come forward to ask for their bottle of champagne. In other words, it really is… bioethics is really… it really is a gross load of nonsense. Safety, of course, and if you’re doing… if you’re doing experiments on animals, you must try not to be… that they don’t suffer too much pain. If you’re doing experiments on people, you have to tell them what you’re actually doing, but I think the bioethic issues related to the… early human embryo, and to cloning, simply have no foundation whatsoever.
Lewis Wolpert (1929-2021) CBE FRS FRSL was a developmental biologist, author, and broadcaster. He was educated at the University of Witwatersrand (BSc), Imperial College London, and at King's College London (PhD). He was Emeritus Professor of Biology as applied to medicine in the Department of Anatomy and Developmental Biology at University College London. In addition to his scientific and research publications, he wrote about his own experience of clinical depression in Malignant Sadness: The Anatomy of Depression (1999).
Title: The nonsense of bioethics
Listeners: Eleanor Lawrence
Eleanor Lawrence is a freelance science writer and editor, and co-author of Longman Dictionary of Environmental Science.
Tags: human embryo, stem cells, ethics, bioethics, cloning
Duration: 2 minutes, 11 seconds
Date story recorded: April 2010
Date story went live: 14 June 2010